Messages from Your Boss Outside Working Hours, Does It Count as Overtime? Understand Your Rights

Introduction

In today’s digital era, the boundary between professional and personal life is becoming increasingly blurred. Due to the convenience of communication technology such as instant messaging applications and email, superiors can easily contact employees at any time, including well beyond the designated working hours. This phenomenon raises questions such as whether employees are obligated to respond to and reply to messages from their superiors. If so, can such work, even if limited to replying to messages, be classified as overtime work?

This situation has the potential to disrupt employees’ rest periods and may increase the risk of mental health issues. Many employees feel pressured to remain responsive because they fear being perceived as unprofessional or lacking a strong work ethic, even though they have already fulfilled their working hour obligations. This also raises fundamental questions regarding the rights and obligations of workers under the laws applicable in Indonesia.

 

Legal Basis

The primary legal framework governing employment relationships in Indonesia is Law Number 13 of 2003 on Manpower (“Law 13/2003”), as amended by the Job Creation Law. The following provisions are relevant to this issue:

1. Working Hours Provisions (Article 77 of Law 13/2003)

This regulation clearly establishes the standard working hour limits for workers/laborers:

• 7 hours per day and 40 hours per week for 6 working days; or 
• 8 hours per day and 40 hours per week for 5 working days.

Article 77 of Law 13/2003 affirms that there is a clear time limit during which a worker is expected to perform their work. Time outside such provisions is, in principle, considered the worker’s rest period.

2. Right to Rest Periods (Article 79 of Law 13/2003)

Law 13/2003 requires employers to provide rest periods to workers/laborers, including breaks during working hours and weekly rest periods. This fundamental right supports the physical and mental recovery of workers and affirms the existence of boundaries that must not be violated between working time and personal time.

3. Overtime Work Provisions (Article 78 of Law 13/2003)

Article 78 of Law 13/2003 stipulates that:

• Employers who require workers/laborers to work beyond standard working hours are obligated to pay overtime wages. 
• Overtime work may only be performed with the consent of the relevant worker/laborer.

Based on Article 78 of Law 13/2003, any work performed under instructions from a superior outside the working hours stipulated under Article 77 of Law 13/2003 may be considered overtime work. This includes activities such as responding to emails or instant messages that require thought, analysis, or work-related actions.

 

Sanctions for Companies that Violate the Provisions

A company’s failure to fulfill its obligation to pay overtime wages is not considered a minor violation. Law 13/2003 provides strict sanctions for companies that neglect this obligation.

Based on Article 187 paragraph (1) of Law 13/2003, companies that violate the obligation to pay overtime wages as regulated under Article 78 paragraph (2) of Law 13/2003 may be subject to criminal sanctions. Such sanctions include:

1. Imprisonment for a minimum period of 1 month and a maximum period of 12 months; and/or 
2. Criminal fines of at least IDR 10,000,000 and up to IDR 100,000,000.

Article 189 of Law 13/2003 further affirms that the imposition of criminal sanctions (imprisonment, confinement, and/or fines) does not eliminate the employer’s obligation to continue paying workers/laborers their rights or compensation. This means that, in addition to facing criminal legal proceedings, the company remains obligated to pay all overtime wages owed to employees.

 

Practical Implications

The legal provisions above give rise to several practical implications that should be understood by both companies and employees:

1. Work Outside Working Hours Constitutes Overtime

Legally, superiors are permitted to give instructions through communication media outside working hours. However, any work resulting from such instructions must be calculated as overtime working hours and is entitled to financial compensation.

2. “Invisible Overtime” and Legal Risks

Many companies do not calculate activities such as replying to instant messages (WhatsApp) as overtime. This may be referred to as “invisible overtime.” Such practices violate working hour and overtime wage provisions and may potentially result in industrial relations disputes.

3. Employees’ Right to “Disconnect”

Overtime work requires employee consent. Therefore, employees fundamentally have the right to refuse or not respond to work instructions outside the designated working hours. Although this may be difficult in practice due to social and professional pressure, this right is protected by law.

Confused by complicated legal provisions? Veritask has AiYU – Legal AI that can help analyze the legal provisions you need in accordance with Indonesian laws and regulations. Try it for free now!

 

Recommendations

To create a healthy and legally compliant employment relationship, several measures may be taken:

For Companies:

1. Establish Clear Policies

Prepare clear rules regarding communication outside working hours within Company Regulations (PP), Employment Agreements (PK), or Collective Labor Agreements (PKB).

2. Respect Rest Periods

Promote a culture of not contacting employees outside working hours except for matters of an urgent nature.

3. Comply with Overtime Procedures

If work outside working hours is genuinely necessary, ensure that it is carried out in accordance with applicable procedures by obtaining prior employee consent and paying overtime wages in accordance with the regulations.

For Employees:

1. Understand Workers’ Rights

Be aware of workers’ rights regarding working hours, rest periods, and overtime wages guaranteed by law.

2. Communicate Boundaries

If communication outside working hours has become disruptive, communicate such boundaries politely and professionally to superiors.

3. Maintain Documentation

Keep records of every instruction and task performed outside working hours as evidence should discussions regarding compensation become necessary in the future.

 

Closing

Based on Law 13/2003, responding to instant messages such as WhatsApp messages and/or work-related emails outside working hours falls within the category of overtime work. Although contacting employees is not prohibited, companies have a legal obligation to provide overtime wages for any work performed as a result.

Respecting the boundary between working time and rest time is not merely an ethical matter, but an essential legal obligation. Compliance with these regulations not only protects companies from the risk of disputes, but also safeguards employees’ welfare and productivity in the long term.